Over 1M Posts • 84K Topics • 9K Authors

Project sound insulation - 6G Celicas Forums

Topic #61981 220 posts Started by GotToyota
>
QUOTE (Galcobar @ Aug 19, 2012 - 4:01 AM) *
>Would it not be better to apply the mass loading material directly to the panels, as the point is to increase their mass and thus reduce the frequency of their vibrations to inaudibility?

Laying the Frost King down first would decouple the dampening material from the panel it's meant to dampen, assuming that the mass loading material doesn't compress the foil to the point where it is unable to function.

The open-cell foam is sound insulation, taking advantage of the inefficiency in sound transmission when soundwaves cross multiple different densities (the open cells force the wave to transition from foam to air to foam repeatedly). The aluminum foil backing is intended to help reflect sound which makes it through the foam.

The other point to be aware of is that the Frost King has a strong adhesive already applied to the foam side. I used aluminum tape for the seams to make them less prone to damage but it wasn't necessary for proper adhesion.



I don't want to use CLD tiles in my case. Mass-loaded Vinyl isn't particularly easy to stick on vertical surfaces. I think you got them confused. MLV is to reduce sound and CLD is to reduce resonance by adding weight.

The usual combo is CLD->CCF (Closed-Cell Foam)-> MLV. I plan on using Frost King with some MLV and some carpet padding. MLV on horizontal surfaces like the floor, and padding on the vertical ones.

>
QUOTE (richee3 @ Aug 19, 2012 - 12:59 PM) *
>I ended up finishing the Celica's trunk in Frost King this morning, and I'll add some to the roof later. I'm putting the GTMat in my 350Z, specifically on the rear fenders. The GTMat looks like it will be a good substitute for Dynamat Xtreme, so I may end up buying some to line my firewall and the underside of my hood with. I really enjoy a quiet car, to say the least.

Syaoran- The carpet padding in the doors is a bit of overkill and adds a decent amount of weight. I have had both Frost King and the carpet padding in my doors at one point and I couldn't hear any difference at all when I took the carpet padding out. Then again, I have a '98 that had some extra sound insulation from the factory and that might make a difference. Under my carpet, I just have Frost King, and that made a big difference. The biggest difference, however, came from lining my rear fender wells and quarter panels with Frost King. Since the fender wells are inside the car in a Celica, you get quite a big of noise from those. Covering the fenders both in the trunk and by the back seats with Frost King cut out the biggest part of my noise, followed by lining the floorboards, then the doors. I currently do not have my firewall or roof lined with anything, but the rest of the body panels in my interior are lined. I'll be curious to see your results.



How much did you use for the rear? I ordered two rolls of 2"x15ft I believe. I'll see how that goes.

1993 Celica GT Coupe - sold1994 Celica GT Liftback
A single roll worked out perfectly for the rear and after driving around some, cut out a decent amount of road noise. Not much exhaust noise, but a decent amount of road noise. I also lined the back wall where I could.

Edit: The rolls I bought were 12"x15', not 2'x15' so you should have plenty. smile.gif

This post has been edited by richee3: Aug 22, 2012 - 10:21 AM

"Employ your time in improving yourself by other men's writings, so that you shall gain easily what others labored hard for." -Socrates. Even Socrates told us touse the search button!2006 Aston Martin V8 Vantage.1998 Celica GT-BEAMSSwapped.2022 4Runner TRD Off Road Prenium.2021 GMC Sierra AT4.
It's actually 2 inches x15ft hehe but we'll see how much two rolls of that covers up. I couldn't find anything bigger and they don't seem to carry it at the local Home Depot

1993 Celica GT Coupe - sold1994 Celica GT Liftback
Ah, gotcha. Yeah, I've had a couple of rolls of that stuff too. It came in handy in quite a few places. Surely you can order the foot wide stuff? It'll go a lot faster with it. smile.gif

"Employ your time in improving yourself by other men's writings, so that you shall gain easily what others labored hard for." -Socrates. Even Socrates told us touse the search button!2006 Aston Martin V8 Vantage.1998 Celica GT-BEAMSSwapped.2022 4Runner TRD Off Road Prenium.2021 GMC Sierra AT4.
>
QUOTE (Syaoran @ Aug 22, 2012 - 9:29 AM) *
>It's actually 2 inches x15ft hehe but we'll see how much two rolls of that covers up. I couldn't find anything bigger and they don't seem to carry it at the local Home Depot


Check Lowe's, their supply of Frost King/Thermwell products seems to be better than that of Home Depot.
>
QUOTE (richee3 @ Aug 22, 2012 - 3:50 PM) *
>Ah, gotcha. Yeah, I've had a couple of rolls of that stuff too. It came in handy in quite a few places. Surely you can order the foot wide stuff? It'll go a lot faster with it. smile.gif


I have patience........... I hope haha

>
QUOTE (Galcobar @ Aug 22, 2012 - 6:46 PM) *
>>
QUOTE (Syaoran @ Aug 22, 2012 - 9:29 AM) *
>It's actually 2 inches x15ft hehe but we'll see how much two rolls of that covers up. I couldn't find anything bigger and they don't seem to carry it at the local Home Depot


Check Lowe's, their supply of Frost King/Thermwell products seems to be better than that of Home Depot.



No Lowe's around here frown.gif Is there any similar product?

1993 Celica GT Coupe - sold1994 Celica GT Liftback
I usually get mine from a different place altogether, Menard's. I'm not sure if they're a local chain or national but they have better prices than Home Depot or Lowe's. PM me if you can't find any of the foot wide stuff and want me to ship you some. Seems like the 2" stuff will cost a lot more by the time you buy enough.

"Employ your time in improving yourself by other men's writings, so that you shall gain easily what others labored hard for." -Socrates. Even Socrates told us touse the search button!2006 Aston Martin V8 Vantage.1998 Celica GT-BEAMSSwapped.2022 4Runner TRD Off Road Prenium.2021 GMC Sierra AT4.
>
QUOTE (richee3 @ Aug 23, 2012 - 7:00 AM) *
>I usually get mine from a different place altogether, Menard's. I'm not sure if they're a local chain or national but they have better prices than Home Depot or Lowe's. PM me if you can't find any of the foot wide stuff and want me to ship you some. Seems like the 2" stuff will cost a lot more by the time you buy enough.


That would be nice. Sending a PM.

1993 Celica GT Coupe - sold1994 Celica GT Liftback
we need pictures...words don't do justice
The corvette guys (older vettes) use a combo of dynamat and the frost king stuff. A little dyna mat to add weight to a few panels and then the entire floor in the frost king to block sound, but in the vette's its used to block the heat as well. My 70' stingray gets a lot of heat bleeding through the firewall and tranny tunnel, almost to the point of being unbearable if I'm driving with sandals or barefoot. (I live near the beach) Anywho, I'm guessing this Frost King stuff will help with the efficiency of the A/C and heating systems in the celica since the car is better insulated.
The original purpose of the Frost King is to insulate HVAC ducting, so it will definately help with in-car HVAC. That Corvette discussion/how-to is what actually got me into using it in the first place.

The link's on the first page of this thread, though it seems to be defunct now. Here's the same how-to, looks like Mercury moved sites: http://tim-yvonne.com/mikemercury/sound.htm

This post has been edited by Galcobar: Aug 25, 2012 - 3:52 PM
is it worth to install Frost King material on a 95 gt4?
actually on the door panels.

FBMay 2015 COTM
>
QUOTE (Red123 @ Jan 28, 2014 - 1:08 AM) *
>is it worth to install Frost King material on a 95 gt4?
actually on the door panels.

Explain how the material looks or works and I can try to help.

FS thread :Custom Celica partsmade to order + moreClick the image to visit my FB page
>
QUOTE (The_enD @ Jan 27, 2014 - 7:12 PM) *
>>
QUOTE (Red123 @ Jan 28, 2014 - 1:08 AM) *
>is it worth to install Frost King material on a 95 gt4?
actually on the door panels.

Explain how the material looks or works and I can try to help.

Thanks. I dont know. here's the link
http://www.homedepot.com/p/Frost-King-E-O-...FV516/100028603

FBMay 2015 COTM
As described the product will isolate the door from weather conditions and reduce vibration, but it's best to be added to the door's sheet metal, not cards.
What effect are you looking for? There are three types of reduction: road noise, vibration of body panels and their resonance, interior rattle.

FS thread :Custom Celica partsmade to order + moreClick the image to visit my FB page
>
QUOTE (The_enD @ Jan 27, 2014 - 7:29 PM) *
>As described the product will isolate the door from weather conditions and reduce vibration, but it's best to be added to the door's sheet metal, not cards.
What effect are you looking for? There are three types of reduction: road noise, vibration of body panels and their resonance, interior rattle.

I want to remove a sound insulation from on a door panels. if it would be ok, I'll try to install that on a carpet too. maybe I'll try.

This post has been edited by Red123: Jan 27, 2014 - 6:40 PM

FBMay 2015 COTM
I cannot understand you frown.gif

FS thread :Custom Celica partsmade to order + moreClick the image to visit my FB page
>
QUOTE (The_enD @ Jan 27, 2014 - 7:38 PM) *
>I cannot understand you frown.gif

I mean sound insulation on a door panels, maybe on a carpet later.

FBMay 2015 COTM
Put the sound deadener under the carpet, directly on the metal.
A very good site to read and buy http://www.sounddeadenershowdown.com/

FS thread :Custom Celica partsmade to order + moreClick the image to visit my FB page
>
QUOTE (Red123 @ Jan 27, 2014 - 4:36 PM) *
>>
QUOTE (The_enD @ Jan 27, 2014 - 7:29 PM) *
>As described the product will isolate the door from weather conditions and reduce vibration, but it's best to be added to the door's sheet metal, not cards.
What effect are you looking for? There are three types of reduction: road noise, vibration of body panels and their resonance, interior rattle.

I want to remove a sound insulation from on a door panels. if it would be ok, I'll try to install that on a carpet too. maybe I'll try.


Choose the source of the sound you want to reduce. The product you choose to install depends on the type of noise you want to reduce.

The FrostKing is good at blocking outside noise from entering the car -- noise from tires, other cars, and to some extent the wind. It is a foam (absorbs noise) backed by foil (reflects the sound waves), best applied to the exterior panels. FrostKing/Thermwell does little to reduce the vibration of body panels, and very little to improve speaker performance. The point of using FrostKing is to make the inside of the car quieter.

If you read the entire thread, you will see it can be used through the entire interior of the car.
I have to disagree with you. Upon further investigation, the weight of Frost king is around 12 times lesser than the weight of a proper sound blocking material (1lb/12ft²). And you need mass to block noise, around 1lb per ft².
To me this product has no application in cars.

FS thread :Custom Celica partsmade to order + moreClick the image to visit my FB page
>
QUOTE (The_enD @ Jan 28, 2014 - 6:44 AM) *
>I have to disagree with you. Upon further investigation, the weight of Frost king is around 12 times lesser than the weight of a proper sound blocking material (1lb/12ft²). And you need mass to block noise, around 1lb per ft².
To me this product has no application in cars.

How can you say that it has no application in cars when so many people have gotten so good results? Is it because it is supposed to be for something else? To me this product seems to be a classic case of 80% of the effect for 20% the price.
There are better products suited for in car installation.
Adding any type of insulation material will yield results since OEM the car is not threated very good and at places there is no deadener at all. This is not a high end luxury vehicle, it's a sporty looking car where price is a concern.
The question is is it worth it at the end, when you can buy products that were designed just for that specific purpose and not for pipes, air ducts and roofs.
There is a huge difference between a properly done car, threated with all three types of deadener, and a car done with some inferior products.

FS thread :Custom Celica partsmade to order + moreClick the image to visit my FB page
I have to say the frost king DID improve sound isolation.

not nearly as quiet as my LS400 but for the 10lbs or so i added to do the WHOLE car, definitely a good trade off.

but YES, something else may do a better job, it will also be heavier.

it also reduces heat transfer

QUOTE"And, as always, your friendship, help, and dedication to the advancement of Texas Celica dominance is GREATLY appreciated. Thanks bro." -DEATH1994 GT:V6 swap, 5speed E53 W/ LSD, All Power, now RED1995 ST:SOLD @273k miles, Auto, all power, CarPC, White1994 ST:Totaled, 5spd, all power, RedRIP 07/09/09 @ 241,8101994 Lexus LS400:This is my new DD
I know that there are better products when it comes to sound dampening. But in our cars where weight and price is a concern, frost king definatly has an application.
For me weight is not a concern, it's a daily car, not a track car.
Neither is price, I prefer to spend more money and do it properly and have much better results.

FS thread :Custom Celica partsmade to order + moreClick the image to visit my FB page
Then frostking has no application in your car:)

But with 1/12 the weight, a fraction of the cost and still good results it's a pretty good deal for most people.
Open cell foam backed by foil is also the preferred means of noise insulation for airplanes. It's used on ducting not nearly so much for heat blocking as for noise -- it's not meant as a vibration dampener.

Mass loading is good at stopping a panel from vibrating, which is absolutely necessary when the source of the noise/vibration is the vehicle itself (either the engine, the body shaking or sound system). It is much less necessary when you're attempting to stop exterior noise from entering the vehicle, in large part because the vibration of the panel from transmitted sound waves is so much weaker. For road noise absorption is almost as effective as mass dampening, without the weight penalty.

If the additional mass, the loss of performance, the degraded fuel economy and the higher cost are irrelevant to your goals, then yes the Frost King is not a suitable product for your application. However, saying it is never a suitable product ignores the fact that it's designed for precisely this task -- absorption and reflection of an external noise source -- which has led to FAA certification for use in airplanes, and the success others have experienced with it.

Better or worse depends upon the goal.
>
QUOTE (Galcobar @ Feb 5, 2014 - 5:15 AM) *
>Open cell foam backed by foil is also the preferred means of noise insulation for airplanes. It's used on ducting not nearly so much for heat blocking as for noise -- it's not meant as a vibration dampener.

Using open cell foam in a car is not preferred as it will absorb water which may lead to rust and smell. Even tho the car is fairly insulated from the outside world, water still penetrates through the doors and moisture in the air.
Not to mention open cell will simply fold in, if there is any pressure applied to it, lessening it's effectiveness.

>
QUOTE (Galcobar @ Feb 5, 2014 - 5:15 AM) *
>Mass loading is good at stopping a panel from vibrating, which is absolutely necessary when the source of the noise/vibration is the vehicle itself (either the engine, the body shaking or sound system). It is much less necessary when you're attempting to stop exterior noise from entering the vehicle, in large part because the vibration of the panel from transmitted sound waves is so much weaker. For road noise absorption is almost as effective as mass dampening, without the weight penalty.

There is a difference between mass loading a panel and mass loaded sheeting.
You don't want your panels vibrating, because that creates noise due to the panel resonating. This is where CLD(Constraint Layer Vibration Damper) tiles come to work. They control resonance, which leads to noise. You can't control resonance with a lightweight foam that effectively.
Just driving down the road creates vibrations through out the whole body of the car.

>
QUOTE (Galcobar @ Feb 5, 2014 - 5:15 AM) *
>If the additional mass, the loss of performance, the degraded fuel economy and the higher cost are irrelevant to your goals, then yes the Frost King is not a suitable product for your application. However, saying it is never a suitable product ignores the fact that it's designed for precisely this task -- absorption and reflection of an external noise source -- which has led to FAA certification for use in airplanes, and the success others have experienced with it.

Better or worse depends upon the goal.

Adding maybe around 20-30 kilograms of sound deadening material is not going to affect the vehicle performance or fuel economy to a point that it will be noticeable. If that's the case people should stop filling up their 60 liter gas tank full, keep their trunk always empty and never drive their children in the back, cause you know, they add weight. Not to mention a grown up person in the passenger seat.
I may have been too harsh when it comes to Frost King, but it's just that there are far better materials for the purpose. I personally like to do thing properly, with product each designed and tested for the purpose of it's use. This is where I will spend my money and time. I won't spend many hours removing interior carpet and panels just to add a inferior material knowing there is something better, even tho more expensive, but will yield a much greater final result.

I suggest you read all the information on this site I posted above:
http://www.sounddeadenershowdown.com/
and the same info, just compacted.
http://store.secondskinaudio.com/

Both a proven companies for sound insulation for cars.

FS thread :Custom Celica partsmade to order + moreClick the image to visit my FB page
I really agree with you that when you are going through all this work with the sound dampening, you might as well use proper materials. But for many people 30kg is alot, especially with a such a light and slightly underpowered car as an st. Having my gf versus a heavy dude as a passanger was very noticable with my 7afe.

I will probably use "silent coat" everywhere in my gt4. With its 2mm thickness i will be able to get a seamless coverage of the entire car. 3kg per kg is not to bad, and with 300hk it will definatly not be noticable.